I like this map, It's good how you kept it simple and organized. the look is consistent throughout and game play is fluid for me.
I remember joining in on multilayer and watching you or one of your friends working on this for a while, good to see it here.

the map is pretty nice and fast.
althoug the theme is almost the same as the map i'm currently making :D

Aesthetics: This map looks very nice, as is usually the norm for Quake maps, although this map did have a very nice twist what with the outside setting. I must say, however, the map was a bit samey what with all the brown everywhere. 4/5.

Gameplay: Extremely fun. I played with five bots and it was mental! 5/5.

Flow: Good space to move around and I never once hit my head on anything, although I did get stuck in the alcove with the shells a few times. 4/5.

Design: Epicly epic. Many alcoves and shelves that look similar to disorient players. A breath of fresh air. It wasn't too overcomplicated either, keeping my computer at a nice steady 50fps. 5/5.

Packaging: I would have liked a waypoint file for bots (/dropwaypoints 1, run around and /savemap), and the picture was origin.JPG which will cause problems for Linux users. Rename it to lowercase. 3/5.

Overall: A great map, which provides ultra fun. Good work! 4/5.

Martinum4, if you rate my map one star, at least give me some helpful advice...

This map is epic, it's UBER

nice map

Martinum4 intentionally does it to lower the map scores. It's a conspiracy.

Good map. The layout is solid and given its simplicity you still put into consideration clip and noclip, etc. to make it function. It's small so only good for a few people, and open so there's nowhere to hide.

Even though you're using one texture set to make it uniform, it's too much. It looks really bland as far as texturing goes because it's ALL brown.. Like, REALLY brown everywhere. So I'd make the texturing more complex, try to use as much of the Gibbie set as possible and maybe cross over into other sets.

no problem 4 my help to btw :P, even redon did the most ;D!

1 more thing: u should change the maptitle (its still "quake-test by Theso")!

More quake maps please :D

i think its way to small. it is good for duel and a max. of 3 players. i played with 5 and it was chaotic.
u should maybe put some things to hide /or not. and maybe a bit bigger.

ah this map brings back my memories of playing quake online (aaah, the good old days). fast paced, plain textured and surprising playtime for a small map. well done.
a negative a small fraction of the lighting on the map is unbalanced but overall this maps good for the fast game play not the design.
I thank you for bring those memories back.

- fix the texturing/geometry at the jumppad to make it more intuitive/believable
- clip that one air-vent-grating-recess where you can currently still walk into (2nd level, diagonally opposite to the jumppad)
- maybe add some "pseudo buildings" to the exterior of the arena to give the map some additional "depth" (pun intended)

I'd vote this at about 3 stars myself .. it's definitely not one of the best maps I've ever seen, so no 5, and even 4 seems too much since there's a good many drawbacks to this specific map, as compared to a map playable with more people on more modes with more space and more details ...
With those five people already giving a 5-star score .. I'm going for a "reduce average more important than personally correct scoring", sorry.

4/5, its optic is trash/booring, but the gameplay is awesome, something really new compared to the release-maps.

improve its optic with adding some details, the map is to "clean" in my oppinion