Very good! It looks kinda out of place because of the chrome/gray skin and green light, while all the other default skins are modernish. This one kinda looks Haloish. There was one part of the firing animation that I didn't get; why is there that roundish tube that sticks out of the back whenever you fire? Sorry if the answer's obvious, I don't know much about Winchesters other than they look cool! 4.5/5, I'll round it to a 5! :p
EDIT: Great job at fixing the "tube bug!" Although now the shell doesn't fly out anymore, but I guess that couldn't be helped. (Or can it? ; ) )

Cool to do new weapon :) I had the same weapon animation idead but with a flying ball (lol), but i'm not good with bones animation i have to read some tutorials :D

But I think You can Do better, i explain:

-the skin: the left face is good, but the top face is bad, textures are ugly, you didn't do a good UV skin, I think that's it. And i don't like the green part :s search some tutorials to do better UV skins and will be good weapon.

-if you don't find, move you model to left/top for we can't seethe top of teh model, or maybe try to rotate a little... you have to try some technics, but i think creat new uv skin skin is better :D

ps: 3/5 for the moment, I'll change if you modify what i said ;) enjoy

Good luck

hey your oviously quite good at skinning new gun models e.t.c:

i was just wondering if you were willing to make a more realistic weapon set?

like an m16/m4/ak47 for assult

mp5/ak74u/uzi for submachine gun

psg1/m4a03 for the sniper rifle

and maybe a desert eagle for the pistol?

if you could do that or any of those that would be amazing!!!

lol desert eagle has been made i have it ill post it up
Hope u like it
NOTE:i didnt make it......